Do you think parents who neglect medical treatment for their children in favour of prayer should be sent to prison if their child dies?
Is it dangerous to tell gullible people to pray when, according to the American Heart Journal, it has no positive medical effects?
http://www.ahjonline.com/article/PIIS0002870305006496/abstract
gary 7 infiltrator, Atheati.
Yes, absolutely. They should go to prison if their child suffers in any way, not just if their child dies.
HaileysMom
Yes, they should go to prison.
Freedom of religion is always used as an untouchable trump card. Well, it's time religious freedom took a backseat to the lives of children.
Rob
No. Parents have a right to practice their religion. I have experienced and seen many miracles of healing.
http://www.dukemednews.org/news/article.php?id=5056
DURHAM, N.C. - Cardiac patients who received intercessory prayer in addition to coronary stenting appeared to have better clinical outcomes than those treated with standard stenting therapy alone, according to researchers at Duke University Medical Center.
Their results further suggest that using rigorous scientific methods to study the therapeutic value of prayer and other noetic interventions appears feasible and warrants larger-scale, more definitive investigations. Noetic interventions are defined as "a healing influence performed without the use of a drug, device or surgical procedure," said the researchers.
Results of the phase I feasibility-pilot, known as the MANTRA (Monitoring and Actualization of Noetic TRAinings) Project, appear in the Nov. 1 issue of the American Heart Journal.
"We now know that clinically meaningful, high-quality research can be done in this area," said Duke cardiologist Dr. Mitch Krucoff, who co-directs the study with Suzanne Crater, a Duke nurse practitioner. "The data are suggestive that there may be a measurable therapeutic benefit related to noetic therapies in patients undergoing angioplasty."
Patients who received noetic therapies showed a 25 to 30 percent reduction in adverse outcomes (such as death, heart failure, post-procedural ischemia, repeat angioplasty or heart attack) than those without such therapies, according to the researchers. While increasingly popular outside of mainstream medicine, noetic therapies have not been widely studied with rigorous, scientific research methods. This study represents one of the first such efforts.
benthic_man
Yup. Freedom of religion aside, there's an easily detectable dividing line between obligations on this plane and the next.
Buddy Christ loves you
Definitely, idiots! They may have the right to practise their religion but their child may have also grown up to be an atheist who would be pissed at the thought of their parents praying when they could have actually been helping. Guess we will never know though......
ineedhelpwithmyselfimage
When they send abortionists to jail as well. Isnt killing a child killing a child?
So many here are pro choice. Guess what, this is choice. Live with it.
sam
Parents who pray and their kids die of something common, yes they should go to court and be judged. If the child has a terminal illness and there are experimental drugs or drugs/treatments that only give them a little while longer, then, no, they should not go to jail. Each circumstance is different and must be dealt with accordingly.
I know a man who was born a "blue" baby and his parents gave him up for dead knowing, back then, there were no treatments. Someone prayed for him and he is now 76 years old. (If I heard him correctly, he was born with a whole in his heart and it is not there.)
MollyMac13
Sending them to prison after their child has died isn't going to achieve anything positive.
It is irresponsible to suggest that prayer can cure but some people find comfort in it.
It's small beans
YES! Recently two young girls were denied medical treatment by their parents. Both of these girls died. They both had type 1 diabetes. If my parents were religious freaks like those parents I wouldn't be here. I've been a diabetic since 1 yr old.
It is truly disgusting! Let them rot in jail for the rest of their miserable lives!
Chaos the Pirate
It's all well and good to have great faith, but a child's health is not something to take chances on. They should be seen as neglectful in the eyes of the law.
Add your own answer in the comments!
Orignal From:
Do you think parents who neglect medical treatment in favour of prayer?